Home › United States › Wisconsin › Milwaukee, Wi
Historic haunted places in Milwaukee, WI. Each page gives the ghost story, whether visitors can go, and a link to the site the story came from. The stories are folklore, not documented fact.
5 listings shown.
Haunted place
Built in 1910, the mansion later served as a Prohibition speakeasy, a home for Lutheran pastors, and a boarding house before becoming a B&B. George Brumder Jr. is said to remain, a…
This story is folklore told about a real place. It is not presented as documented fact.
Haunted place
Former director Stephan de Borhegyi died in a 1969 car crash on his way to work, and some believe he never left. On the third floor, near his portrait, people report a caped figure…
This story is folklore told about a real place. It is not presented as documented fact.
Haunted place
Staff have reported seeing founder Charles Pfister since his death in 1927, and in the 2000s visiting Major League Baseball players began sharing their own unsettling stays. Some p…
This story is folklore told about a real place. It is not presented as documented fact.
Haunted place
Housed in an 1894 former speakeasy, the bar has promoted its resident ghosts for decades and runs in-house ghost tours. Brave guests can book a night in its reputedly haunted penth…
This story is folklore told about a real place. It is not presented as documented fact.
Haunted place
The 1926 Eagles Club's long-empty swimming pool is the center of its best-known tale: performers say they have seen a young girl's spirit there, believed by some to have drowned. A…
This story is folklore told about a real place. It is not presented as documented fact.
Milwaukee's haunted map is a bar, a hotel, and three walking routes through the old industrial city — and unusually for this series, the bar and the hotel document their own pasts on their own sites.
The bar is Shaker's Cigar Bar, in the historic Walker's Point neighborhood. Shaker's own site, collected, dates its building to 1894 and lists its lives in one sentence: it "has served as a cooperage, a Prohibition-era speakeasy and brothel, and today stands as one of the city's most celebrated dining and hospitality destinations." The business itself dates to 1986, per the site — "Since 1986, we've built our reputation on world-inspired cuisine, handcrafted cocktails, rare vintage spirits, boutique wines, premium cigars" — under owner Bob Weiss, at 422 S. 2nd St., Milwaukee, WI 53204. AAA's TripCanvas listing for its ghost tour adds the name the operator's own homepage leaves out: a "former Al Capone-owned speakeasy," in AAA's words.
The hotel is The Pfister Hotel. Its own site says it has stood as an iconic Milwaukee landmark since 1893 — "A palace For The People," "Historic Milwaukee Hotel Since 1893," at 424 East Wisconsin Ave., Milwaukee, WI 53202, near the historic Third Ward. FOX6's collected account adds the documented frame: the hotel "opened its doors in 1893. It was built by businessman Guido Pfister and his son, Charles," holds what FOX6 describes as the largest Victorian art collection of any hotel in the world, and is "often a temporary home for U.S. presidents, celebrities and athletes."
The walking routes are American Ghost Walks', and its Milwaukee page frames the city its tours walk: "A city shaped by industry, corruption, and ambition," whose history "is built on hard labor, rapid growth, and a reputation that wasn't always clean. From breweries and warehouses to grand hotels and civic buildings, the city's rise brought both opportunity and tragedy." Its Milwaukee operation dates to 2008 — its Third Ward walk is billed as "Milwaukee's original tour since 2008."
This section is folklore — reported by the sources cited, and never asserted as fact here.
The Pfister's legend is the best-documented, because named people told it to named news organisations. FOX6's account reports that for years MLB players visiting Milwaukee have reported spooky encounters at the hotel — "disembodied voices or unexplained footsteps," in its summary. Its centrepiece is on the record: in 2009, then-Minnesota Twins outfielder Carlos Gomez told the Associated Press that he heard voices in his room, that his iPod "went on the fritz, changing his music and playing an eerie static tone," and that the moment sent him running to the lobby straight from the shower, without pants or shoes. "I'm scared to go there," Gomez told AP. "They should change the hotel." FOX6 records that on his next stay he brought a Bible for protection. Phillies star Bryce Harper is quoted with a second account: waking to find his clothes on the floor and the table moved against the opposite wall, the door still latched. FOX6 also reports that some players refuse the hotel altogether — Dodgers shortstop Mookie Betts books an Airbnb in Milwaukee, and Teoscar Hernandez and his wife switched hotels during the 2025 National League Championship Series after she heard the stories. As for who the ghost is said to be: "Some people believe that Charles Pfister haunts the hotel," FOX6 reports, and it quotes the hotel's own general manager, Joe Kurth, telling AP in 2009 that any encounter with him would be friendly — "The ghost is described as a portly gentleman with a smile," Kurth said, "here to make sure that his brand of hospitality still exists within the hotel today." That is a hotel management blessing its own legend, and it is reported here as exactly that.
Shaker's lore, by contrast, is reported about the building rather than pinned to a named witness in the material collected here. AAA's listing describes "countless stories of unexplained encounters reported by guests, staff, paranormal investigators, and visitors from around the world," and a tour through "three levels of history and lore" hearing "accounts of unexplained experiences, lingering spirits, and the darker chapters of Milwaukee's past." Those are the tour's own accounts as AAA retails them — attributed, and at that strength here.
American Ghost Walks publishes its Milwaukee legends as route teasers, and they are presented here as the operator's teasers, nothing more: on the Third Ward walk, "Clair Richardson haunts the Cabot"; on the Shadow of City Hall walk, "occult lore" and "Milwaukee's most famous haunt"; on the Brady Street walk, "tales of crisis apparitions, elementals & exorcisms" alongside the street's Mafia history. Its stories are delivered on the walks; the page does not publish them in full.
Hountix lists 5 places in Milwaukee, WI. Seasonal attractions keep their own open dates, so check each business's own site before you go.
Shaker's is a cigar bar first and a ghost tour second, and its own homepage, collected, is unusually candid about both. "Nestled in Milwaukee's historic Walker's Point neighborhood, Shaker's Cigar Bar has welcomed guests from around the world for more than 40 years," it says. "Housed inside an 1894 building with an extraordinary past, Shaker's Cigar Bar has served as a cooperage, a Prohibition-era speakeasy and brothel, and today stands as one of the city's most celebrated dining and hospitality destinations." It dates the business to 1986, names owner Bob Weiss, and lists what it runs today: live music, "immersive historic, ghost, true crime, or Mafia tours," dinner, and "an overnight stay in our famous penthouse." Its address, published on the site, is 422 S. 2nd St., Milwaukee, WI 53204, phone (414) 272-4222.
The ghost tour itself is described most fully not on the bar's homepage but on AAA's TripCanvas listing for it, and this story attributes the description to AAA accordingly. "Step inside a former Al Capone-owned speakeasy and explore nearly two centuries of history, mystery, and reported paranormal activity," AAA writes. "The Original Ghost Tour takes guests through three levels of history and lore, uncovering the people, events, and stories that have shaped the building for generations… Part history tour, part paranormal experience, this immersive guided tour offers a unique opportunity to explore one of Milwaukee's most storied buildings after dark. Not for the faint of heart." AAA puts the duration at one hour and ticket prices starting from $36. Note the layering honestly: the 1894 date and the speakeasy-and-brothel chapter are the bar's own account; the Capone ownership is AAA's claim, not stated on the bar's homepage in the material collected here; and the paranormal content — "unexplained encounters reported by guests, staff, paranormal investigators, and visitors," per AAA — is reported experience, retold on the tour.
Confirm current tour times and prices on the bar's site before going; its homepage carries Tours, Hours and Contact pages the collector's standard paths did not reach.
*Website: http://www.shakerscigarbar.com/*
The Pfister is the haunted stay rather than a haunted attraction, and — exactly as with the grand hotels in earlier cities in this series — its story starts with what its own site does not say. The Pfister's homepage, in the material collected, is a hotel site: "A palace For The People," "Historic Milwaukee Hotel Since 1893," rooms, dining, spa, weddings, and a Condé Nast Traveler readers' choice billing — and no ghost story, no haunted claim, nothing. The haunting of the Pfister is reported about the hotel by journalists and ballplayers, never sold by the hotel itself — with one charming exception, its own general manager's on-the-record blessing of the legend, quoted in the city story above.
The documented frame is solid. The hotel's own site dates it to 1893 and gives its address as 424 East Wisconsin Ave., Milwaukee, WI 53202, phone (414) 273-8222. FOX6's account adds that it was built by businessman Guido Pfister and his son Charles, holds the largest Victorian art collection of any hotel in the world, and regularly hosts U.S. presidents, celebrities and athletes — which is precisely why its legend has named witnesses: the visiting teams stay here. The legend itself, in full, is in the city story above: Carlos Gomez's 2009 AP account of voices and a misbehaving iPod and a shoeless run to the lobby; Bryce Harper's moved table and latched door; Mookie Betts' Airbnb; the Hernandez hotel switch during the 2025 NLCS; and the belief, reported by FOX6, that Charles Pfister himself is the presence — a "portly gentleman with a smile," per his own hotel's manager, still checking on the hospitality.
Practically: this is a working luxury hotel, booked through its own site; there is no ghost tour to reserve and no lore on its site to check. Whether a given ballplayer sleeps here in a given October is, on the evidence collected here, a genuinely open question each postseason.
*Website: https://www.thepfisterhotel.com/*